Friend of Seth

Mitchell, along with Jimmy, arrive at Seth;'s house the evening Aislinn intends to meet Keenan at the carnival. In addition to being a friend of Seth's, Mitchell also dated Aislinn's friend, Leslie. Ash describes Mitchell as worse than a loudmouth, particularly since "Leslie had told everyone who'd listen that he was a lousy lay."

Mitchell brings a six pack as well as three girls with him. The guys weren't invited. Seth gently hints to Mitchell he and Aislinn would like to have time to themselves, but Mitchell denies this and pops open a can of beer.

Unbeknownst to Mitchell, Jimmy or Seth, at least one of the other girls isn't mortal but Fey. The one Ash identifies as a faery, Cerise, seems to be trying to entice Seth to leave the train with her. Ash confronts Cerise, which Mitchell thinks is "fun." His own date comes to stand next to him while he teases Seth about sharing his "secrets." Mitchell says Seth doesn't have any trouble getting dates, but he is amazed Aislinn, who "hardly even speaks" is "ready to start a fight over him."

Aislinn and Cerise exchange words with Ash ultimately throwing Cerise out of the train, causing Jimmy, Mitchell and the other girls to leave, too.